Food was actually fantastic! Everything was fresh! Jordyn was a great server and was careful to listen to my requests. I actually ordered the Chicken Milanese by accident and it was good
Loud and crowded. Our server Elena was sweet and friendly. The pretzels with cheese was pretty good. My dad enjoyed the pulled pork sandwich. The chicken club was decent, they were able to handle my moms food allergies. They brought me the wrong side but quickly fixed it. I didn’t particularly enjoy my impossible burger, it was dry and the toppings were kinda non existent (lettuce/tomato).
If you love clean ingredients, a nice ambiance, and great service for dinner I HIGHLY recommend Libby’s! I don’t usually order Caesar salads as an entree because they’re often not filling or super flavorful. BUT, this salad was soooo satiating and packed with flavor for dinner! The salmon was cooked to perfection and the kale was softened to perfection! The dynamite shrimp were also amazing (more mildly flavored). A great experience in Sarasota for date night!
Update (01/23/22) The GM Matt was very kind as we sat on the patio outside( it was chilly) offered us both a cup of coffee while we waited. Loved the fact that he came outside to check on us. So far Dylan is a good server, quickly brought us our waters and took our order, after he put in our order he came back to check on us and see if we wanted any cocktails. So far so good. Now will the food be as good as Kyle's customer service? The food looks alot better. So this time we got the brunch burger(absolutely delicious and juicy) the fries( the parm fries are so 👌 especially if you pair it with there hollandaise...divine) perfectly crisp. Also the hollandaise was perfect it wasn't like butter this time. The French toast: smores(not enough marshmallow but once they brought some more it was absolutely delicious) bananas foster(this is not your traditional foster it's more like banana de Leche but that's not a bad thing cause it's still delicious). And then finally the American breakfast eggs cooked correctly this time our server was thoughtful and brought jelly and butter with the English muffin. And man are those potato cakes delicious. The fruit needs to be trimmed a little better there was some rind still on the watermelon. They experience overall was an Astounding A+. Well done to Matt and his team they step up to the plate and hit home run this time can't wait to try those tri-tip egg rolls. Me and my partner order the American breakfast (her eggs were raw), smores French toast(not enough marshmallow spread), Banana fosters French toast (no Carmel sauce), and finally the shrimp and crab Benedict ( which the hollandaise was broken and runny as well as rubber shrimp. But the crab and eggs were cooked to perfection.) I don't know if we just had a one off experience but maybe lunch is better. Also the fruit was so sweet and delicious. Kyle the bartender and management saved this experience not only handling this professionally but offering to fix the experience swiftly.
7pm reservation and got on right on time. Good start. I did ask for indoor seating but the hostess took us outside. It ended up being alright because the inside is very small and tight. Volume was overwhelming inside. I ordered the NY Strip, it only comes with fries which is alright if the steak was good. Very thin, fatty and the garlic butter herb sauce on top, was good but wasn't on the steak. The Special for Beef Short Ribs, I tried and they were very good. Disappointed however overall.
For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!